Jump to filters & categories ↓

Vintage

Furrever Friends Blushytail Kitty Cat Kitten Plush Kenner 1986 3 tails FREE SHIP

Furrever Friends Blushytail Kitty Cat Kitten Plush Kenner 1986 3 tails FREE SHIP

$79.99 USD
Free shipping
Douglas Cuddle Toys Long Hair Plush Tan & Brown Cat

Douglas Cuddle Toys Long Hair Plush Tan & Brown Cat

$45.00 USD
Free shipping
Very Rare Vintage Gigglee Eyes Monster Plush Set 1988 My Pet Monster

Very Rare Vintage Gigglee Eyes Monster Plush Set 1988 My Pet Monster

$4999.99 USD
Free shipping
Tyco Dsi Kitty Kitty Kittens

Tyco Dsi Kitty Kitty Kittens

$65.00 USD
Vintage Rushton Like Gund Chicken Vintage Rubber Face

Vintage Rushton Like Gund Chicken Vintage Rubber Face

$150.00 USD
$25.00 shipping
1989 Lost 'n Founds PRETTY KITTY Crying Baby Cat Plush Galoob Opened Unplayed

1989 Lost 'n Founds PRETTY KITTY Crying Baby Cat Plush Galoob Opened Unplayed

$79.99 USD
Free shipping
Vintage American Coin Merchandising Butterfly Plush Stuffed Carnival Prize Toy

Vintage American Coin Merchandising Butterfly Plush Stuffed Carnival Prize Toy

$16.99 USD
$4.50 shipping
Vintage composition Face Kitty Cat

Vintage composition Face Kitty Cat

$250.00 USD
Vintage Laramie Interests Plush Kitty Cat Purple Stuffed Animal Collectible Toy

Vintage Laramie Interests Plush Kitty Cat Purple Stuffed Animal Collectible Toy

$19.99 USD
$4.50 shipping
Tyco Kitty Kitty Kitten Plush Patches White Tan Gray Calico Cat Purple Collar 92

Tyco Kitty Kitty Kitten Plush Patches White Tan Gray Calico Cat Purple Collar 92

$89.99 USD
Smurf Smurfette Hugging 11" Stuffed  Plush Toy Wallace Berrie Co Vintage 1982

Smurf Smurfette Hugging 11" Stuffed Plush Toy Wallace Berrie Co Vintage 1982

$19.99 USD
$4.79 shipping
Vintage Leather Stuffed BrownBear Japan Tommy Mid Century 1960s Original Sticker

Vintage Leather Stuffed BrownBear Japan Tommy Mid Century 1960s Original Sticker

$45.00 USD
Vintage Dandee Christmas Plush Mice Couple Mouse stuffed Animal Holiday

Vintage Dandee Christmas Plush Mice Couple Mouse stuffed Animal Holiday

$29.99 USD
$12.00 shipping
Vintage Bim Zippy Monkey Plush Doll Rubber Face 16"

Vintage Bim Zippy Monkey Plush Doll Rubber Face 16"

$61.00 USD
Lot of 3 Vintage Tyco DSI Kitty Kitty Kittens Puppy Puppy Puppies cat dog plush 

Lot of 3 Vintage Tyco DSI Kitty Kitty Kittens Puppy Puppy Puppies cat dog plush 

$98.00 USD
$9.60 shipping
1979 North American Bear Company Queen Elizabear 21” Chicago, IL

1979 North American Bear Company Queen Elizabear 21” Chicago, IL

$38.95 USD
Ace Novelty Co Vintage Korea Plush Stuffed Poodle Dog Gray 17”

Ace Novelty Co Vintage Korea Plush Stuffed Poodle Dog Gray 17”

$34.99 USD
$10.56 shipping
Vtg 1990 Dakin Elephant Musical Trunk Plush When You Wish Upon A Star *See Video

Vtg 1990 Dakin Elephant Musical Trunk Plush When You Wish Upon A Star *See Video

$85.01 USD
Vintage 1980 Francesca Hoerlein Le Mutt Plush Dog “VERY LOVED” Yellow Eyes G5

Vintage 1980 Francesca Hoerlein Le Mutt Plush Dog “VERY LOVED” Yellow Eyes G5

$69.99 USD
$9.99 shipping
Vintage Ganz Wrinkles Puppy Boy Dog Hand Puppet 18” Stuffed Animal

Vintage Ganz Wrinkles Puppy Boy Dog Hand Puppet 18” Stuffed Animal

$20.00 USD
Vintage Ganz Wrinkles Puppy Boy Dog Hand Puppet 18” Stuffed Animal

Vintage Ganz Wrinkles Puppy Boy Dog Hand Puppet 18” Stuffed Animal

$20.00 USD
English Vintage Dressed Stuffed Glass Eyes Rabbit Doll

English Vintage Dressed Stuffed Glass Eyes Rabbit Doll

$30.00 USD
$12.50 shipping
VINTAGE DOUGLAS CUDDLE TOY RUBBER HEAD SANTA SUIT RARE BABY BOY DOLL

VINTAGE DOUGLAS CUDDLE TOY RUBBER HEAD SANTA SUIT RARE BABY BOY DOLL

$20.00 USD
$7.95 shipping
Vintage Rubber Face Plush Purple Fox

Vintage Rubber Face Plush Purple Fox

$300.00 USD
VIntage 1979 Daekor Teddy Bear 12" Plush Good Condition!

VIntage 1979 Daekor Teddy Bear 12" Plush Good Condition!

$34.99 USD
$5.99 shipping
Vintage Santa Baby Sassy Cat 1981 Christmas Musical Plush Toy Pink Sings WORKS

Vintage Santa Baby Sassy Cat 1981 Christmas Musical Plush Toy Pink Sings WORKS

$79.99 USD
Free shipping
Vintage Corky Clown Rare Thumb Sucker California Toys Doll Plush Red Blue Circus

Vintage Corky Clown Rare Thumb Sucker California Toys Doll Plush Red Blue Circus

$23.99 USD
Free shipping
VINTAGE PINK SOFT BODY RUBBER HEAD DOUGLAS BABY DOLL MID CENTURY PONYTAIL TOY

VINTAGE PINK SOFT BODY RUBBER HEAD DOUGLAS BABY DOLL MID CENTURY PONYTAIL TOY

$20.00 USD
$7.95 shipping
Dogz Jowls The Dog Plush 1997 Trendmasters Interactive Sound

Dogz Jowls The Dog Plush 1997 Trendmasters Interactive Sound

$29.99 USD
vintage jerry elsner musical Giraffe teddy plush 9” tall

vintage jerry elsner musical Giraffe teddy plush 9” tall

$25.00 USD
Free shipping
24K Polar Puff 1985 by Special Effects 1985 Brown Bear

24K Polar Puff 1985 by Special Effects 1985 Brown Bear

$24.99 USD
Vtg Zippy Monkey Plush Stuffed Doll Rubber Face Banana Yellow Black Mr Bim Zip

Vtg Zippy Monkey Plush Stuffed Doll Rubber Face Banana Yellow Black Mr Bim Zip

$99.00 USD
$14.00 shipping
Vintage Primitive Stuffed Bear Well Loved Old & Worn Stands Upright 13”

Vintage Primitive Stuffed Bear Well Loved Old & Worn Stands Upright 13”

$60.00 USD
Free shipping
 14 garfield plush dakin   Collection  1978-1981

14 garfield plush dakin Collection 1978-1981

$200.00 USD
Free shipping
RARE Vintage Tiger Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Cat Green Eyes 9.5” X 8”

RARE Vintage Tiger Plush Toy Stuffed Animal Cat Green Eyes 9.5” X 8”

$19.95 USD
$6.00 shipping
Vintage Lisa Frank Black Boopsidoodle Bunny Easter Plush Beanie

Vintage Lisa Frank Black Boopsidoodle Bunny Easter Plush Beanie

$500.00 USD
Free shipping
Vintage Rubber Face  Defenders Of Nature 22 “Brand VIR Spain

Vintage Rubber Face Defenders Of Nature 22 “Brand VIR Spain

$545.00 USD
Vintage Rare Original Sigikid W. Germany Plush Mouse Toy EXC

Vintage Rare Original Sigikid W. Germany Plush Mouse Toy EXC

$30.00 USD
Anva International Beaver Puppet

Anva International Beaver Puppet

$19.99 USD
$5.00 shipping
Twinkle Bear Purple Plush 1995 Lights Up Push Nose & Tongue Working GREAT SHAPE

Twinkle Bear Purple Plush 1995 Lights Up Push Nose & Tongue Working GREAT SHAPE

$139.99 USD
Vintage 40-50s Stuffed plush Cat rubber muzzle red hat & bow

Vintage 40-50s Stuffed plush Cat rubber muzzle red hat & bow

$78.00 USD
Free shipping
Bunny Rabbit  Felt Pillow Vintage 1950s Toy

Bunny Rabbit Felt Pillow Vintage 1950s Toy

$29.95 USD
$9.95 shipping
Puppet Mohair POODLE Dog Hand Puppet 1950s Vintage Cream Colored Snobby Cousin

Puppet Mohair POODLE Dog Hand Puppet 1950s Vintage Cream Colored Snobby Cousin

$55.00 USD
$9.95 shipping
Vintage 1985 Hasbro Softies Sesame Street 30" Large Plush Big Bird

Vintage 1985 Hasbro Softies Sesame Street 30" Large Plush Big Bird

$61.95 $52.66 USD
Free shipping
Rare Variant Set 1986-1990 My Pet Monster  Plush Stuffed Animal AmToy

Rare Variant Set 1986-1990 My Pet Monster Plush Stuffed Animal AmToy

$599.99 USD
$18.00 shipping
1980 Sendak WHERE THE WILD THINGS ARE Bernard 11" Plush Doll  Vintage.

1980 Sendak WHERE THE WILD THINGS ARE Bernard 11" Plush Doll Vintage.

$25.00 USD
Vintage Rubber Face  Plush Sleepyhead Doll

Vintage Rubber Face Plush Sleepyhead Doll

$215.00 USD
VTG 1998 Lisa Frank Bean Buddy Buddies Rose Ballerina Bunny Rabbit Plush

VTG 1998 Lisa Frank Bean Buddy Buddies Rose Ballerina Bunny Rabbit Plush

$29.99 USD
Amtoy My Monster Pet RARK 1986 Vintage Hand Puppet Stuffed Plush Doll CLEAN

Amtoy My Monster Pet RARK 1986 Vintage Hand Puppet Stuffed Plush Doll CLEAN

$75.00 USD
Vintage Kenner 1989 Hallmark Yum Yums Goody Grape Mouse 13” Purple Plush

Vintage Kenner 1989 Hallmark Yum Yums Goody Grape Mouse 13” Purple Plush

$60.00 USD
$7.99 shipping
Vintage 11" Drooper Dog Yellow With Brown Ears Nutshell Stuffed

Vintage 11" Drooper Dog Yellow With Brown Ears Nutshell Stuffed

$49.99 USD
Free shipping
2 x Sumsi Bee Plush Raiffeisen Bank Wien Yellow 12"

2 x Sumsi Bee Plush Raiffeisen Bank Wien Yellow 12"

$42.99 USD
Vintage Mattle Magic Nursery Pet Green Cat 1990 Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

Vintage Mattle Magic Nursery Pet Green Cat 1990 Plush Stuffed Animal Toy

$43.99 $39.59 USD
Free shipping
Vintage Advertising Plush 1990 Teddy Grahams Chicken Of The Sea Idaho Potato Lot

Vintage Advertising Plush 1990 Teddy Grahams Chicken Of The Sea Idaho Potato Lot

$49.99 USD
Antique Vintage Ram Taxidermy Toy Real Wool

Antique Vintage Ram Taxidermy Toy Real Wool

$26.25 USD
RARE Afghan/Poodle Hound Dog Leather Stitched Plush Stuffed Animal Toy - Japan

RARE Afghan/Poodle Hound Dog Leather Stitched Plush Stuffed Animal Toy - Japan

$19.99 USD

Brand

Size

Shop For

Age Level

Shop by Category